
MODELING NOTES FOR ASHRAE STANDARD 140

 Carrier 2023.  All rights reserved.

===============================================================================
A. SOFTWARE INFORMATION
===============================================================================
1. SOFTWARE VENDOR:   Carrier Corporation

2. SOFTWARE NAME:     Carrier Hourly Analysis Program

3. SOFTWARE VERSION:  6.1.0.1054

4. OPERATING SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS:
                      Windows 10,
                      Windows 11
					  
5. APPROX HARD DISK SPACE REQUIRED FOR INSTALLATION:
                      Typical = 1 GB

6. MINIMUM RAM REQUIRED FOR SOFTWARE OPERATION:
                      8 GB

7. MINIMUM DISPLAY MONITOR REQUIREMENTS:
                      XGA with 1024x768 resolution and 256 colors

===============================================================================
B. REPORT BLOCK FOR ALTERNATIVE MODELING METHODS
===============================================================================

NOTE 1 - Equipment Characteristics (5.2.1.13.2)
---------------------------------------------------------
Simulated Effect:  

Specified Cooling and Heating Capacity

Alternative Methods: 

Autosized cooling and heating capacity is used. The autosized capacity is enough to meet the zone cooling and heating load all the time.

===============================================================================
C. REPORT BLOCK FOR EQUIVALENT MODELING METHODS
===============================================================================

NOTE 1 - Internal Heat Gains
         (Section 5.2.1.7)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.1 Effect Being Simulated:
    Internal Heat Gain (Radiative/convective split)

1.2 Section(s) of the Standard where Relevant Inputs are Specified:
    5.2.1.7

1.3 Equivalent Input(s) Used:
    480 W Electric Equipment Heat Gain
	-280 W Other Equipment Heat Gain


1.4 Physical, Mathematical or Logical Justification of the Equivalent Input(s) 
     provide supporting calculations, if relevant:
    
	In HAP, direct specification of radiative/convective split is not supported.
	The electric equipment heat gain assumes 25% radiative, 75% sensible convective.
	The Other Equipment Heat gain is assumed to be 100% sensible convective.
	
	So the combined effect of these two heat gain is:
	
	Radiative: 480 W * 0.25 = 120 W
	Convective: 480 W * 0.75 - 280 W = 80 W
	This is equivalent to the specified 200W heat gain with 60% radiative (120 W), 40% convective (80 W).


===============================================================================
D. REPORT BLOCK FOR USE OF NON-SPECIFIED INPUTS
===============================================================================
 NONE


===============================================================================
E. REPORT BLOCK FOR OMITTED TEST CASES AND RESULTS
===============================================================================

NOTE 1 - In-Depth Test Cases
         (Section 5.2.3)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.1 List the Case(s) where Results Were Omitted, and which Results Were Omitted
    for the Case(s):

    220   210	215
	200	  195	230
	240	  250	270
	280	  290	300
	310	  320	400
	395	  410	420
	430	  440 	800
	810


1.2 Explanation for Omitting the Test Case(s) Results:

	These test cases require indepth modeling features that are not available through the 
	user interface of HAP. Since the required input parameters are beyond what a regular 
	HAP user would modify, these test cases cannot be performed. 

===============================================================================
F. REPORT BLOCK FOR CHANGES TO SOURCE CODE FOR THE PURPOSE OF RUNNING THE 
   TESTS, WHERE SUCH CHANGES ARE NOT AVAILABLE IN PUBLICLY RELEASED VERSIONS OF 
   THE SOFTWARE
===============================================================================

NOTE 1 - Night Ventilation Schedule (Section 5.2.2.1.5.1.1)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.1 List the Change(s) to the Source Code:
	No modification was made to the source code. However, the changes were made to the HAP 
	generated EnergyPlus input data file to accurately model the night ventilation schedule
	specified in Section 5.2.2.1.5.1.1. The ventilation schedule in NightVentilationSchedule.IDF
	is used to replace the zone exhaust fan schedule in the HAP generated EnergyPlus IDF file
	for the simulation.

1.2 List the Test Case(s) Relevant to the Change(s) in the Source Code:
	Case 650, Case 950.

1.3 Explanation of Why the Change is Not Included in the Publicly Released 
    Version of the Software:

	Currently in HAP, the zone exhaust fan schedule follows the air system schedule, the night ventilation
	schedule specified in 5.2.2.1.5.1.1 cannot be modeled by inputs specified in the user interface. To 
	test the building load calculation, it is justified to manually change the HAP generated EnergyPlus
	input data file.



===============================================================================
G. REPORT BLOCK FOR ANOMALOUS RESULTS
===============================================================================
HAP results for Annual Cooling Load and Peak Cooling Load are outside the range of reference program results 
for a number of the test cases.  This is because of the indoor convection algorithm used by HAP.  
The Section 5.2 test cases implicitly require modeling of natural convection within the space. That represents 
an application where there is no forced airflow such as supply airflow or  ventilation  essentially radiant 
cooling and radiant heating with no ventilation.  The only air movement in the space is due to natural 
convection bouyancy effects of warm or cool surfaces.  HAP is designed to model HVAC systems commonly used in commercial 
buildngs, so it models forced air cooling and heating systems that include ventilation.  The presence of air 
circulation due to forced air HVAC results in higher surface convection coefficients and a higher rate of 
convective heat transfer between surfaces and room air than in a room having no forced airflow at all.  
As a result, conversion of envelope and internal heat gains to load is faster than in a room with no airflow. 
That causes higher peak cooling loads and in some cases higher annual cooling load to occur than in the reference results. 
When we manually manipulated the HAP data passed to EnergyPlus for calculation to replace the forced air convection model 
with the natural convection model, the calculation results aligned well with the reference program results. 
That result demonstrates the natural convection issue is responsible for deviation of HAP's original test results.


===============================================================================
<END OF DOCUMENT>
===============================================================================
