

MODELING NOTES FOR ASHRAE STANDARD 140

© Carrier 2023.  All rights reserved.

===============================================================================
A. SOFTWARE INFORMATION
===============================================================================
1. SOFTWARE VENDOR:   Carrier Corporation

2. SOFTWARE NAME:     Carrier Hourly Analysis Program

3. SOFTWARE VERSION:  6.1.0.1054

4. OPERATING SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS:
                      Windows 10,
                      Windows 11
					  
5. APPROX HARD DISK SPACE REQUIRED FOR INSTALLATION:
                      Typical = 1 GB

6. MINIMUM RAM REQUIRED FOR SOFTWARE OPERATION:
                      8 GB

7. MINIMUM DISPLAY MONITOR REQUIREMENTS:
                      XGA with 1024x768 resolution and 256 colors

===============================================================================
B. REPORT BLOCK FOR ALTERNATIVE MODELING METHODS
===============================================================================

NOTE 1 - Adiabatic Bounrady Condition  (5.5.1.4)
---------------------------------------------------------
Simulated Effect:  

Test specifications in 5.5.1.4 requires adding large amount of insulation to the wall, floor and roof assembly to 
model near adiabatic boundary condition.

Alternative Methods: 

Instead of adding insulation to the wall, floor and ceiling material assembly, in the HAP building model,
"unmodeled space" was added on the outside of each surface, in HAP this feature automatically imposes 
adiabatic boundary condition on the surface, therefore it will achieve the same objective as the test
specification.

===============================================================================
C. REPORT BLOCK FOR EQUIVALENT MODELING METHODS
===============================================================================

NONE


===============================================================================
D. REPORT BLOCK FOR USE OF NON-SPECIFIED INPUTS
===============================================================================
 NONE


===============================================================================
E. REPORT BLOCK FOR OMITTED TEST CASES AND RESULTS
===============================================================================

NONE

===============================================================================
F. REPORT BLOCK FOR CHANGES TO SOURCE CODE FOR THE PURPOSE OF RUNNING THE 
   TESTS, WHERE SUCH CHANGES ARE NOT AVAILABLE IN PUBLICLY RELEASED VERSIONS OF 
   THE SOFTWARE
===============================================================================
NONE

===============================================================================
G. REPORT BLOCK FOR ANOMALOUS RESULTS
===============================================================================

NOTE 1 - Fan Coil System Configuration  (5.5.1)
---------------------------------------------------------
1.1 Test Case(s) and Specific Results from the Case(s) that are Anomalous:
AE101, AE103, AE104: In the detailed outputs for these cases, the heating coil outlet (hco),
cooling coil outlet (cco) and supply air (sa) state variables do not follow the system schematic
described in Figure 5-25. 

1.2 Explanation of Reason for the Anomalous Results:
The reason for the anomalous result is that the modeled FCU uses a different configuration than whe is 
specified in Figure 5-25. The modeled system has the following dequence:

Outdoor Air Mixer --> Supply Fan --> Cooling Coil --> Heating Coil--> Zone

So this is a blow-through configuration with cooling coil upstream of heating coil.

Thus in the detailed outputs table, the difference between the Mixed Air and Cool Coil Outlet is 
the combined effect of the Supply Fan and the Cooling Coil. The difference between the Cool Coil Outlet and 
Heat Coil Outlet is the effect of the heating coil heating. The Heat Coil Outlet is same as the Supply Air. 

NOTE 2 - Zero Bypass Factor for cooling coil
---------------------------------------------------------
2.1 Test Case(s) and Specific Results from the Case(s) that are Anomalous:
AE104, AE204, AE206, AE226, AE304, AE306, AE404: The cooling coil outlet Relative Humidity in the summary table is not at saturation (94.5%).

2.2 Explanation of Reason for the Anomalous Results:
The reason for this result is that currently in HAP zero bypass factor cannot be specified for a cooling coil. 

NOTE 3 - Single Zone System Configuration
---------------------------------------------------------
3.1 Test Case(s) and Specific Results from the Case(s) that are Anomalous:
AE201, AE203, AE204, AE205, AE206, AE226, AE245.

For these single zone system cases, the modeled system configuration is different from Figure 5-27 in that the cooling coil is upstream
of the heating coil. 

Outdoor Air Mixer --> Cooling Coil --> Heating Coil--> Supply Fan --> Zone

The schematic in Figure 5-27 is the following configuration

Outdoor Air Mixer --> Heating Coil --> Cooling Coil--> Supply Fan --> Zone

3.2 Explanation of Reason for the Anomalous Results:

The reason for this result is that currently in HAP model assumes cooling coil to be upstream of heating coil for a single zone system. 

===============================================================================
<END OF DOCUMENT>
===============================================================================
